Heat pump or electric hot water for a Boronia home?
When an old electric cylinder fails, many Boronia households ask whether to replace like for like or switch to a heat pump. Here is how they compare.
- Licensed Victorian plumbers
- Based in Boronia, City of Knox
- Price agreed before work
- Night and weekend call-outs
Running costs
An electric storage unit heats water with an element, turning electricity directly into heat. A heat pump moves heat from the air into the water, using far less electricity for the same hot water. For most households, a heat pump costs much less to run each year.
Upfront cost
Electric storage units are usually cheaper to buy and install, especially as a like-for-like swap. Heat pumps cost more upfront, though government programs have at times reduced this. Over the life of the unit, lower running costs often make up the difference.
Climate
Boronia is cooler than inner Melbourne, and hill streets are colder still. Heat pumps lose some efficiency in cold weather and reheat more slowly, but quality models are designed to keep working in cold conditions. Electric elements are unaffected by air temperature.
Space and noise
Electric units can go in cupboards and tight spots. Heat pumps need open air and make a fan noise similar to an air conditioner, so placement near bedrooms and neighbours matters.
Solar panels
If you have rooftop solar, a heat pump timed to run in the middle of the day can use your own power, cutting costs further. An electric unit can also be timed to solar, but uses more of it.
Which suits you?
- Electric storage suits small households, tight spaces and those wanting the lowest upfront cost.
- Heat pumps suit most families planning to stay, especially with solar, and anyone wanting lower running costs.
We can look at your home and give you an honest recommendation. See our heat pump hot water page.
More guides
Send us the job details
Send the details and a licensed plumber from Boronia will call you back. Water flooding or a sewer overflowing? Do not wait for a reply, ring 03 8804 5837 now.
Every job is quoted on what we actually find. That is why you will not see a price list on this site.
Plumbing problem in Boronia?
Ring a local licensed plumber. You hear the price before any work starts.